#1001544 please UNMUTE a tab when user changes sound volume

Package:
firefox
Source:
firefox
Description:
Mozilla Firefox web browser
Submitter:
Eduard Bloch
Date:
2021-12-11 23:27:04 UTC
Severity:
important
#1001544#5
Date:
2021-12-11 23:25:34 UTC
From:
To:
Hello,

recently I was was hit by the issue demonstrated in
https://askubuntu.com/questions/967061/firefox-keeps-resetting-pulse-volume-to-0
and this is a UX issue which FF should solve.

What is happening here? I am not sure (exatly). Maybe the Tab was muted
by me, or maybe it was muted by opening multiple YT tabs. Not sure.

The point is: I start playing some YT video. And there is basically NO
SOUND. I still CAN click on the audio settings of the audio player and
change the volume. And I still don't hear anything. The YT audio icon is
"apparently" not showing my audio status as muted, so I expect something
to be audible.

Next act: I open pavucontrol and see that there is an active stream from
FF but the volume is 0. Why 0%? Dunno, I can change it to something and
then I can her the sound. But only for a short while, after the track
changes, the sound volume returns to 0% again. WAT?

The mentioned askubuntu posting explains the reason for the strange
behavior. But it's really surprising. And it's really hard to spot, the
only indication of the mute-forcing behavior is a thin gray line in an
icon of the tab.

Please CHANGE THIS. Make the user aware of the brute-force-muting
behaviour of FF by showing a flashy "soundblock" icon on that tab.
AND:
when $USER tried to change volume, it should be unmuted, not ignored.

Best regards,
Eduard.