#1005316 telegram-desktop: music resumes after a call, even if the call has been very long and it’s the middle of the night

Package:
telegram-desktop
Source:
telegram-desktop
Description:
fast and secure messaging application
Submitter:
Alexandre François Garreau
Date:
2022-02-12 17:39:02 UTC
Severity:
minor
#1005316#5
Date:
2022-02-11 06:23:31 UTC
From:
To:
Dear Maintainer,

I was calling a friend for quite long until late at night (5am), and at some point internet access (which is actually mobile broadband) went away (which is common with mobile data).  So the call unexpectedly ended.  However, since the call was long (several hours) I forgot about the music, and the hour was very different, involving very different social norms (and laws as well, as in france it is forbidden to do excessive noise (music, etc.) at night between 10pm and 6am) about noise.  I have an insomniac flatmate, so this is especially disturbing in my case. I could switch off the music rapidly but the damage already has been done.

So it would be nice either to break, or make diseablable in multimedia settings the resume of music after a call, either any call, or a too long call.

A further questioning I have is if such a disabling of a eventually disturbing feature is a minor “cosmetic” bug, or a wishlist, I’d like to know your opinion and the general one among DDs.

Another one is if it permitted to report bugs that are very likely, or even obviously, not about or even because of Debian, but of upstream, and to get them upstream, in the (current) case of impossibility to report bugs without proprietary software or unacceptable CGU (from github).

Thank you

#1005316#10
Date:
2022-02-12 13:43:18 UTC
From:
To:
Hello!

Did you use headphones for the call but the music went to speakers? Did
you mean Telegram in-app player or some other program like Rhythmbox or
MPlayer?

There is already a similar bug report in the upstream tracker but closed
for no reason. https://github.com/telegramdesktop/tdesktop/issues/5177

It sounds like feature-not-bug problem. I personally do not think it
really matters. 😌️

You may report issues with Telegram or suggest ideas on
<https://bugs.telegram.org/> site. You can login there through Telegram,
however, it is not possible without JavaScript.

And in my opinion, it is maintainer's task to forward any bugs that
arise in Debian and come from upstream to original authors.

#1005316#15
Date:
2022-02-12 16:30:15 UTC
From:
To:
Le sabato, 12-a de februaro 2022, 14-a horo kaj 43:18 CET Nicholas Guriev a écrit :

No, the other one did, not me, because I was doing other stuff involving moving a lot like
cooking

Telegram’ player ofc

Whaat? It’s weird… I guess they decided they disagreed and it wasn’t worth their (scarce)
time…

…but the last message, from the same person as who closed the issue, references this
previous issue: https://github.com/telegramdesktop/tdesktop/issues/3854[1]

Where such behavior was explicitely requested (even more actually, since it was requested
to work with other programs, which would be damn great :o).  So I guess they decided
«since two users disagree, let’s agree with the one that requires the least effort»…

Ofc the ideal solution would be a multimedia setting, but I don’t know how much additional
work is that.  Likely nonneglictible in comparison, as I imagine it’s already possible to just
break such behavior by changing a single couple of chars in the appropriated place of
source.

Ok thank you very much for your answer! It was actually the second question for which I
wanted an answer the most (that bugreport was kinda a try)

Some ppl are eager to reclassify bugs very promptly while being strongly opinionated
about it… so I kinda expected that more :'D and I have to tell I like when stuff are clear and
well ordered!

Wait how are these two statement compatible? Telegram doesn’t include javascript does it?
or do you merely mean one can login there through Telegram credentials?

Oh okay thank you :o (that was actually the first question whose I wanted to know the
answer with that report) Maybe I’ll report suggestions to you then, although I’m afraid of
overwhelming you, given telegram’s size and current quantity of bugs (I was myself
subjects to crashes a long time ago)

I also wish I could help more, given how often I use it, but I can’t even manage compiling it
^^'
-------- [1] https://github.com/telegramdesktop/tdesktop/issues/3854