#1104182 util-linux-extra: Please include lsclocks in util-linux-extra

Package:
util-linux-extra
Source:
util-linux-extra
Description:
interactive login tools
Submitter:
Witold Baryluk
Date:
2025-04-27 13:42:02 UTC
Severity:
normal
#1104182#5
Date:
2025-04-26 23:14:05 UTC
From:
To:
lsclocks is a handy small utility added in 2023 for checking timers and
clocks and their resolution.

Also, I noticed few other utilities missing, like addpart, delpart. And
no mention of this in README.Debian.

Also some old utilities are gone (probably a good decission), like pg,
and line, but these decisions are not documented in README.Debian
either.

Some others are mentioned in NEWS.Debian.gz, but I think it should be
mentioned in README.Debian too, which tools were intentionally disabled
/ removed.

Cheers.

#1104182#10
Date:
2025-04-27 13:39:09 UTC
From:
To:
Hi Witold,

thank you for the report.

* Witold Baryluk <witold.baryluk@gmail.com> [250427 01:18]:

Agreed. It's not packaged yet because it was unclear how wide the
audience really is, and moving it between packages later is a pain.
You filed this bug against util-linux-extra, so I think you would
like to see it in util-linux-extra?

For some programs we document the reason in debian/not-installed in
the source.

For line, the git history tells me line is deprecated, and was
removed before buster. The same is true for pq.

Indeed, where programs are not built by upstream's default choices,
there's no documentation on it. line, pq were mentioned in
util-linux's NEWS because Debian -used- to ship them, and upstream
deprecated them. But this NEWS entry is so old, that I've removed it
for trixie. Personally I'm not a fan of keeping a "history" document
around, when we can look at the git history :-)

I've stopped installing addpart, delpart in Debian revision 2.40-1,
on my understanding that partprobe, (k)partx or a number of other
tools can be used instead.

Chris