- Package:
- release-notes
- Source:
- release-notes
- Submitter:
- Thorsten Glaser
- Date:
- 2025-07-19 00:15:02 UTC
- Severity:
- normal
- Tags:
Several packages have dropped cronjobs in favour of systemd timers or somesuch, despite these not being covered by the GR about init scripts. The release notes should contain a complete list of all packages that did that, so that affected sysadmins (even systemd users who prefer to keep using crond) can add back the proper cronjobs (there was a mention of a tool to autogenerate them from the systemd units on the init-diversity mailing list, which (anyway) I Cc’d in this bug, so they can chime in).
Thorsten, Thanks for raising this important issue. utrans[1] can produce cron or xinetd fragments from timer units. It can also produce LSB initscripts or openrc runscripts from service and socket units. [1] https://tracker.debian.org/utrans Mark
if someone provides a list of which packages did this, i can help write the text. I assume this should exclude packages that added a timer and made the cron-job do nothing if /run/systemd/system was present -- most packages did that, i think (to me, there doesnt seem any point in including a generic statement about this in the release-notes without a list of packages: systemd is already the default so this issue will only affect people who have chosen to use something else and who are, presumably, more likely to be more aware that there is a risk of this.