- Package:
- libreoffice-calc
- Source:
- libreoffice-calc
- Description:
- office productivity suite -- spreadsheet
- Submitter:
- Nicolas Patrois
- Date:
- 2026-05-13 02:43:26 UTC
- Severity:
- normal
- Tags:
Dear Maintainer, In the diagram window, there are some representation errors: * In bar diagrams, when we chose cones or pyramids, the volumes of the cones or pyramids are not proportional with the values (but their height is proportional with the value, here is the error). * In circle diagrams, the check box to create fake 3D diagram is still there. It should not because the area of what’s seen is not proportional with the values. I know that these representations are popular but if they are false or erroneous, they should be fixed. Yours, nicolas
forwarded 1133354 https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=171724 thanks Hi, Am 12.04.26 um 13:03 schrieb Nicolas Patrois: some? Why one report then? This makes forwarding extra hard since if I forward this to one bug they will react the same as I do now. Two separate issues in one bug? If I split them marking them as forwarded is bad. (And I am not fixing it myself in any case.) :/ (I will NOT intervene when upstream decided to close this.) Put into https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=171724 as-is. Regards, Rene
forwarded 1133354 https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=171724 thanks Hi, Am 12.04.26 um 13:03 schrieb Nicolas Patrois: some? Why one report then? This makes forwarding extra hard since if I forward this to one bug they will react the same as I do now. Two separate issues in one bug? If I split them marking them as forwarded is bad. (And I am not fixing it myself in any case.) :/ (I will NOT intervene when upstream decided to close this.) Put into https://bugs.documentfoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=171724 as-is. Regards, Rene
Le 12/04/2026 à 13:51, Rene Engelhard a écrit : Hello, All of them are in the same sub-window, that’s why I filed one bug instead of two or three. Of course because it’s an upstream bug (I checked the right checkbox). As you wish… OK, thank you. Yours, n.
Am 12.04.26 um 14:05 schrieb Nicolas: Aha. Makes sense. That was not 100% clear from your text... "diagram window" can mean many things... And you didn't read the pretext.. :) I personally think upstream bugs belong upstream and have no place here. Playing proxy just doesn't make sense, since the submitter knows best what is the issue. Especially for bugs like this which are not RC anyway, so no need to fix it before upstream does (or not..) (BTW, which checkbox? Please don't tell me you use a graphical thingy not even showing the bug presubj text. That at least would explain your reports...) > > (I will NOT intervene when upstream decided to close this.) > As you wish… See above. (The play proxy thing.) Regards, Rene
Le 12/04/2026 à 14:18, Rene Engelhard a écrit : Sorry for not having been clear. I did not find what I missed in the pre-text because I don’t use LibreOffice elsewhere than in Debian. I disagree with you. If there is an upstream check box, there is a reason. As far as I remember, it was not here when I first filed bugs. If you find that this entry in the checkboxes should not be here, you may file a report against bugreport. ;) A proxy is not useless. A proxy filters bad reports (oopsie), dupes… A proxy knows the package, its bugs, features and so on, better than a simple user like me, even if I report bugs since a long time in Debian (and some of them might not be perfectly reported or written, of course). The graphical thingy shows the pre-text, the non-graphical thingy shows checkboxes before filling the report. Yours, n.