#253115 mailutils: Dependency on mysql libs should be recommends/suggests.

Package:
mailutils
Source:
mailutils
Description:
GNU mailutils utilities for handling mail
Submitter:
Christopher Cashell
Date:
2025-11-22 21:45:02 UTC
Severity:
wishlist
Tags:
#253115#5
Date:
2004-06-07 09:46:15 UTC
From:
To:
I'd like to request that the dependency on libmysqlclient10 be changed
to suggests or recommends.  My experience is that most (all?) of the
mailutils applications/tools can be used without MySQL (or its client
library) being present, and many of us have no desire to have unecessery
(and unwanted) libraries installed.

Thanks for your time.

#253115#30
Date:
2021-02-22 17:44:41 UTC
From:
To:
Control: found -1 1:3.11.1-5

On a quite bare-bones system, I wanted to install 'at' which then wanted to
install MySQL, MariaDB and PostgreSQL libraries.
I noticed it before on other (bare-bones) systems, where I needed f.e. a
(simple) MTA (for cron's local mail), which (quite understandably) depended on
mailutils and that brought in those DB libraries.

I understand that some people may want to have support for *a* database (thus
and OR relation seems more appropriate), but most people don't need or want
that. Can't the database support be split off into another package which
mailutils then recommends (or suggests)?

Diederik

#253115#43
Date:
2025-11-22 21:19:44 UTC
From:
To:
There was initial work on turning much of mailutils' functionality into
loadable modules 7-10 years ago.  With 1:3.19-1 this appears to have been
completed.  In particular notice /lib/<triplet>/libmu_*.so.9.0.0 for
each module.

I would actually prefer for every module to be a distinct package
(#1121221), but merely splitting "auth" out would remove the concerning
dependencies.

Now all the other packages which make it difficult to install anything
without *both* PostgreSQL and MariaDB...