#344598 lynx: Doesn't follow page navigation links in multipage display of lists.debian.org

Package:
lynx
Source:
lynx
Description:
classic non-graphical (text-mode) web browser
Submitter:
Ross Boylan
Date:
2015-03-06 11:27:04 UTC
Severity:
wishlist
#344598#5
Date:
2005-12-23 23:42:53 UTC
From:
To:
I used lynx to go to lists.debian.org | user lists | kde | Nov 2005
This got me the first page of the lists for November; the top line
indicated there were 4 pages.  However, the navigation links at the
top and bottom of the list to get to the other pages didn't work.

Previous page and next page were not active (in the case of previous
page that's not surprising).  Links shows as "|<" and ">|" where
active, as were first and last page.  However, every link I tried
(using right arrow) left me (or moved me back to) the first page.

This is actually pretty serious, because I can't see the later
entries.  I'm trying to see if someone had a problem similar to mine
(which is preventing me from using a graphical browser....).  I know
there are other search options, and maybe if I were clever I could
figure out the URL to get to the next page....

I haven't noticed this problem with firefox.

I suppose there's an outside chance this is a problem with the way
lists.debian.org is showing the pages.  If that turns out to be the
case, please reassign appropriately.

This is probably an example of some more general problem, but since I
don't know what, I'm letting you know the specific difficulty.

Thanks.

#344598#10
Date:
2005-12-24 00:39:53 UTC
From:
To:
lynx is counting 4 pages of display.  But that's not the same as a webpage.

The navigation links on this page are using a different count - they're
referring to different webpages rather than pages of display.

It's easy to see this by viewing the page's html (by pressing a backslash
in lynx to toggle source-view).  The links that show up in lynx like this:

   |<
   [first page] <
   [previous page] Page 1 of 1 >
   [next page] >|
   [last page]

all point to "threads.html", which is the page you're looking at.

#344598#15
Date:
2005-12-24 06:13:35 UTC
From:
To:
Thank you for the information.  So this report was based on my
misunderstanding, and I think it would be OK to close.

However, it might be possible to change things so this
misunderstanding is less likely.  Perhaps the header could say "Screen
1 of 4" or something like that.  But there may be other web sites that
refer, on the web site, to different screens, so I'm not sure that
would be an advance over the current setup.

If you think some clarification is possible and desirable, you might
leave this a wishlist or low priority item.

Ross

#344598#20
Date:
2005-12-24 10:57:30 UTC
From:
To:
right - screens and pages are often used interchangeably.  Even "document"
can have different meanings according to context.

I'll think about it and see if some better wording comes to mind (nothing
at the moment).

#344598#25
Date:
2005-12-26 22:21:53 UTC
From:
To:
It might be a matter of the display rather than the words, though no
great ideas come immediately to mind.

On the words, which currently are like (p2 of 6), maybe say
(lynx screen 2 of 6).

I think that would be clearer, except perhaps when visiting the lynx
site or the lynx help :)

Ross

#344598#30
Date:
2008-07-19 09:16:56 UTC
From:
To:
Hello,

FWIW lynx-cur 2.8.7dev9-1.2 still uses the same wording, saying
"debian-kde Nov 2005 by thread (p1 of 5)" in the title page.
cu andreas