Hi,

first, thanks for packaging gnome-phone-manager.
Then, I have a problem with it: it looks like my phone isn't supported
so I can't be notified when I receive new messages. I have a Nokia 5500.
It's a Series60 v3. Here's the output of gnome-phone-manager:

[xav@bip:~]$ gnome-phone-manager
** Message: bdaddr 00:18:0F:9F:F6:30
** Message: New connection device is 00:18:0F:9F:F6:30 (changed)
** Message: New connection device is 00:18:0F:9F:F6:30 (not changed)
** Message: Connecting...
** Message: Status 1
** Message: Making serial port connection
conn_complete:  status 0x00

(gnome-phone-manager:4392): GConf-CRITICAL **: gconf_engine_set_string: assertion `g_utf8_validate (val, -1, NULL)' failed

** (gnome-phone-manager:4392): WARNING **: Model Nokia not supported natively
** Message: Using driver 'AT'
** Message: Status 2
** Message: Serial port connected
** Message: Connected to device on 00:18:0F:9F:F6:30
** Message: Exiting connect thread
** Message: driver doesn't support sms nots
** Message: emitting battery

(gnome-phone-manager:4392): GLib-GObject-WARNING **: IA__g_object_set_valist: object class `GtkAboutDialog' has no property named `program-name'
** Message: New connection device is 00:18:0F:9F:F6:30 (not changed)
** Message: Can't connect twice
** Message: emitting battery

Does that look fixable ?

Thanks,
	Xav

severity 441627 wishlist
thanks

Il giorno lun, 10/09/2007 alle 19.33 +0200, Xavier Bestel ha scritto:
Hi Xavier,
thanks to you for your bug report, :)

Unfortunately, I suppose this problem related to your mobile model,
connecting to a phone that support the sms notify you should get a
console output like this one:

** Message: bdaddr 00:0F:DE:C3:35:38
** Message: New connection device is 00:0F:DE:C3:35:38 (changed)
** Message: New connection device is 00:0F:DE:C3:35:38 (not changed)
** Message: Connecting...
** Message: Status 1
** Message: Making serial port connection
conn_complete:  status 0x00

** (gnome-phone-manager:25917): WARNING **: Model AAB-1021041-BV not
supported natively
** Message: Using driver 'AT'
** Message: Status 2
** Message: Serial port connected
** Message: Connected to device on 00:0F:DE:C3:35:38
** Message: Exiting connect thread
** Message: driver supports sms notifications
            ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

I can fill a bug to upstream author asking him to support Nokia 5500,
please tell me the output of:

$ gnome-phone-manager --identify 00:18:0F:9F:F6:30

In the meantime I've changed the severity of the bug to wishlist.

Cheers,

Le lundi 10 septembre 2007 à 20:22 +0200, Francesco Namuri a écrit :

Very strange .. it looks like we're both using the same 'AT' driver ...

Unfortunately it doesn't tell much:

[xav@bip:~]$ gnome-phone-manager --identify 00:18:0F:9F:F6:30
model: 'Nokia'


Thanks,
	Xav

Il giorno lun, 10/09/2007 alle 20.52 +0200, Xavier Bestel ha scritto:

The AT driver is the more generic, phone-manager uses this one when
there is no other native/specific driver to use, it interrogate the
phone using the standard AT strings to know what features the mobile
supports, it's like your phone don't support the sms notification (maybe
the string "driver supports sms notifications" is deceptive, I think
that "mobile support sms notifications" could be better)
Consider that phone-manager uses the gnokii infrastructure, if you see
http://www.gnokii.org/faq.shtml#models, Nokia 5500 is not supported by
any specific driver, so it falls back to generic AT driver, my
SonyEricsson k700i too it's not supported by any native driver, but I
think that it haves a more complete AT command subset.
I'll forward this thread to the upstream author...

Cheers,

------- Messaggio inoltrato -------
-- 
Francesco Namuri
francesco(at)namuri(dot)it   http://namuri.it/
id gpg key: 21A4702A         accipiter@jabber.org

Hi Xavier,
just a ping, have you news about the problem?
have you tried to follow the instructions from
Bastien to give him more information regarding the bug?

cheers,
francesco

Sorry, I didn't receive the last mail to #441627.
I'll do what it says.

	Xav

Hi,

here are the files. I'll add them directly to upstream's bugzilla too.

Thanks,

	Xav

from Bastien Nocera
http://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=441627

"
This message probably came from another device, rather than your phone:
(gnome-phone-manager:4392): GConf-CRITICAL **: gconf_engine_set_string:
assertion `g_utf8_validate (val, -1, NULL)' failed

Could you please attach the output of "hcitool scan" (redirected
directly to a
file)? There should be a device with non-UTF8 characters in the name.

As for the 5500, it is unsupported by gnokii in gnapplet, and the AT
mode won't
do SMS on that phone. Could you attach the output of "sdptool browse
00:18:0F:9F:F6:30"? Hopefully, it will show if we can detect this
phone with
something other than the AT connection.
"

bye
francesco

tags 441627 - moreinfo
retitle 441627 gnome-phone-manager: Nokia 5500 support
thanks

Hi,
I think that, for the next time, it could be a good advice to continue
discussing a bug where it
has been opened. I think that if a maintainer forwards a bug to the
upstream, it's a maintainer task to continue the argument with the author.
This to avoid confusion (like the one in this bug).

Cheers,
francesco

tags 441627 - moreinfo
retitle 441627 gnome-phone-manager: Nokia 5500 support
thanks

Hi,
I think that, for the next time, it could be a good advice to continue
discussing a bug where it
has been opened. I think that if a maintainer forwards a bug to the
upstream, it's a maintainer task to continue the argument with the author.
This to avoid confusion (like the one in this bug).

Cheers,
francesco

Yeah sure, I'm sorry I just wanted to speed things up a bit (I ended up
discussing with upstream directly over irc because even upstream
bugzilla was too slow).
Anyway, the warning is fixed upstream but the initial request is not. I
still have some work to do on my side (try some AT commands, but I can't
seem to make minicom work over rfcomm), I'm not finished with this bug
yet ! Upstream closed it but I'll reopen it eventually when I have more
infos :)

Thanks,
	Xav

[...]

ok, I seen that the author as added the Nokia 5500 to be managed with the
standard AT commands, this in the CVS version of gnome-phone-manager.
I leave the bug in the debian BTS opened until you confirm that it works
with your mobile, if you open directly another bug in bugzilla let me
know.

Hi,
just a ping to known any news about this problem with version 0.40 of
g-p-m...

Cheers,
francesco

Le lundi 26 novembre 2007 à 22:55 +0100, Francesco Namuri a écrit :

Still there, I didn't have time to try new AT codes on my phone ...

	Xav

Hi Xav,
just a ping...

Any news?

Francesco

Il giorno ven, 30/11/2007 alle 18.52 +0100, Xavier Bestel ha scritto:
-- 
Francesco Namuri
francesco(at)namuri(dot)it   http://namuri.it/
id gpg key: 21A4702A         accipiter@jabber.org

Dear submitter,

as the package gnome-phone-manager has just been removed from the Debian archive
unstable we hereby close the associated bug reports.  We are sorry
that we couldn't deal with your issue properly.

For details on the removal, please see https://bugs.debian.org/1014063

The version of this package that was in Debian prior to this removal
can still be found using http://snapshot.debian.org/.

Please note that the changes have been done on the master archive and
will not propagate to any mirrors until the next dinstall run at the
earliest.

This message was generated automatically; if you believe that there is
a problem with it please contact the archive administrators by mailing
ftpmaster@ftp-master.debian.org.

Debian distribution maintenance software
pp.
Thorsten Alteholz (the ftpmaster behind the curtain)