#621000 please complete/update WPA/wireless setup documentation

Package:
ifupdown
Source:
ifupdown
Description:
high level tools to configure network interfaces
Submitter:
Eduard Bloch
Date:
2021-01-21 16:36:02 UTC
Severity:
normal
#621000#5
Date:
2011-04-05 18:42:17 UTC
From:
To:
The current discussion on debian-devel reminded me on the fact that
interfaces file documentation really sucks for regular users. It was
written seven years ago, and even at that time Wireless LAN was becoming
popular as a way to connect workstation systems.

But in the manpage, there is not a single occurence of WPA. That is what
people look for! There is not a single example for wireless LAN or even
WPA in ifupdown examples documentation, AFAICS.

It only refers to iwconfig in the SEE ALSO section. With some luck you
can spot the hint about wireless(7) manpage which is hidden in the last
paragraph of some chapter in the middle of the text. There is more stuff
to read, references to DEBIAN 3.0 and SUSE 8.0 and pcmcia package. Yeah.
Seriosly, WHO CARES?

And following the references in wireless(7), we find more interesting
stuff... oh look, they even explain "encryption", looks like that's it.
But... NO, after our newbie user spent hours on that topic, she learns
that the key information it's still somewhere else.

So, IMHO there should be an example like the one in
http://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/2011/04/msg00184.html
placed on a prominent place in interfaces(5).

And in any case, wireless(7) shall be dropped or updated, and in the
former case it should be mentioned more visibly.

Regards,
Eduard.

#621000#10
Date:
2021-01-21 16:22:31 UTC
From:
To:
It would indeed be a good idea to get around documenting this.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
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=V3C8
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----