- Package:
- x11-xserver-utils
- Source:
- x11-xserver-utils
- Description:
- X server utilities
- Submitter:
- Martin Vegter
- Date:
- 2021-07-09 16:57:07 UTC
- Severity:
- normal
- Tags:
The packages x11-xserver-utils and x11-apps both depend on cpp. Since these are "miscellaneous assortment of X applications" and not development tools, I think they should not depend on cpp. There are people like myself, who like to keep their installations clean and minimal, without packages that they don't need. Or am I mistaken and cpp is needed for x11-xserver-utils to work? I am using Debian Wheezy
It is needed by xrdb. In x11-apps I have not found any reference to
cpp, so the dependency should probably be removed there.
Cheers,
Sven
control: tag -1 patch Here is a trivial patch that makes it possible for the user to choose (as a non-default option) to exclude cpp packages from xorg using systems, at the cost of possibly breaking xrdb. Best wishes, Mike
With a patch moving the dep to a recommends it would be useful if xrdb was configured with something like:
Hi, * Michael Gilbert [Tue Jul 21, 2015 at 11:20:04PM -0400]: I'd very much appreciate, if that patch (which moves cpp from Depends to Recommends) could be considered for inclusion. xrdb *seems* to work for me also without cpp available, and it also supports a `-nocpp` option and also supports specifying a preprocessor of custom choice via `-cpp ....`. x11-xserver-utils requires only ~523 kB of disk space, while cpp and its cpp-10 pulls in >26 MB of disk space, which is quite notable e.g. for live systems. :-/ regards -mika-